Evaluating Sources: A Grade 12 Worksheet
This worksheet helps 12th-grade students practice evaluating the credibility, relevance, accuracy, and bias of various sources for research.
Includes
Standards
Topics
Evaluating Sources: A Grade 12 Worksheet
Name:
Date:
Score:
Carefully read each question and follow the instructions. This worksheet is designed to help you practice evaluating the credibility, accuracy, relevance, and potential bias of various sources. Your ability to critically assess information is crucial for academic success and informed decision-making.
1. When evaluating the credibility of an online article, which of the following is the MOST important factor to consider?
The website's aesthetic design and layout.
The author's credentials and expertise on the topic.
The number of comments and shares the article has received.
The use of complex vocabulary and jargon.
2. A primary source is generally considered more reliable for historical research because:
It is usually longer than a secondary source.
It offers a firsthand account or original data.
It has been peer-reviewed multiple times.
It is always found in print, not online.
3. A source with a clear political agenda can still be useful for research if its bias is acknowledged and considered.
True
False
4. Scholarly articles are always completely free of bias because they undergo peer review.
True
False
Complete the following sentences about the CRAAP test for source evaluation.
5. The 'C' in CRAAP stands for , which asks about the timeliness of the information.
6. The 'A' (first) in CRAAP refers to , examining the importance of the information for your needs.
7. The 'P' in CRAAP stands for , which prompts you to consider the reason the information exists.
8. You are researching the impact of social media on teenage mental health. You find an article published on a personal blog written by a parent, detailing their observations about their own child. Discuss the strengths and weaknesses of this source for your research, considering its potential relevance, credibility, and bias.
9. In academic research, it is often said that all sources have some degree of bias. Discuss the ethical considerations involved in using sources that you identify as biased. How can a researcher responsibly incorporate biased information into their work without compromising the integrity of their argument or misrepresenting the facts? Provide specific strategies for mitigating the impact of bias when presenting research.