Exploring Dialectical Thinking
This worksheet introduces 7th-grade students to dialectical thinking, encouraging them to explore opposing viewpoints and synthesize new understanding.
Includes
Standards
Topics
Exploring Dialectical Thinking
Name:
Date:
Score:
Read the passages and questions carefully. Think about different sides of an issue and how they connect to form a new understanding.
The School Uniform Debate
Many schools across the country have adopted uniform policies, while others strongly oppose them. Proponents of school uniforms argue that they create a more disciplined learning environment, reduce distractions related to clothing choices, and decrease economic disparities among students. They believe that when students are dressed similarly, the focus shifts from fashion to academics, and bullying based on clothing can be minimized. Furthermore, some argue that uniforms instil a sense of unity and pride in the school community.
On the other hand, opponents of school uniforms assert that they stifle students' individuality and self-expression. They argue that clothing is a key way for adolescents to express their personality and creativity, and uniforms take this away. Critics also point out the financial burden uniforms can place on low-income families, especially when students grow quickly or uniforms need frequent replacement. Some also believe that uniforms do not truly address the root causes of bullying or academic struggles, which often extend beyond clothing.
1. What is one argument in favor of school uniforms?
They allow for greater self-expression.
They reduce economic disparities among students.
They are always cheaper than regular clothes.
They encourage more diverse fashion trends.
2. What is a main argument against school uniforms?
They promote a sense of unity.
They can be a financial burden for families.
They improve academic focus.
They reduce bullying.
Complete the sentences with a word or phrase that represents an opposing viewpoint found in the passage.
3. One argument for uniforms is that they create a more disciplined environment, while an argument against is that they stifle students' .
4. Proponents believe uniforms reduce distractions, but critics argue they don't address the of bullying.
5. Using ideas from both sides of the debate, suggest a compromise or a new perspective on school uniforms that addresses some of the concerns. Explain your reasoning.
6. Dialectical thinking involves only considering one side of an argument.
True
False
7. The goal of dialectical thinking is to find a completely new solution from two opposing ideas.
True
False
8. Think of a current issue in your school or community that has at least two strong, opposing viewpoints. Briefly describe the issue and the two main viewpoints.
9. Based on your answer to question 8, how might dialectical thinking help people understand the issue better or find a solution?