Assessing Source Credibility
A Grade 9 ELA worksheet focusing on identifying and evaluating the credibility of various sources for research.
Includes
Standards
Topics
Assessing Source Credibility
Name:
Date:
Score:
Read each question carefully and provide thoughtful responses. This worksheet will help you practice evaluating the credibility of sources for your research projects.
1. Which of the following is the MOST important factor in determining the credibility of a source?
The website has many colorful images.
The author is an expert in the field and the information is peer-reviewed.
The information is easy to read and understand.
The website appears at the top of a Google search.
2. A .org website domain always indicates a credible and unbiased source.
True
False
3. When evaluating a source, it is important to consider the author's and whether they have any that might influence their information.
4. A credible source will usually provide to other sources or research to support its claims.
5. The of a source refers to how current and up-to-date the information is.
6. Explain the difference between primary and secondary sources. Give an example of each.
7. You are researching the impact of social media on teenage mental health. Describe two types of sources you would consider highly credible for this topic and explain why.
8. Information found on a personal blog is generally considered a highly credible source for academic research.
True
False
9. A source published 15 years ago about current internet usage trends would likely be considered outdated.
True
False
Read the following scenario and answer the questions that follow.
Maria is writing a research paper on the effects of climate change on polar bear populations. She finds an article online titled 'Polar Bears: Thriving, Not Dying!' published on a website called 'ClimateTruth.org'. The article argues that polar bear populations are actually increasing and that concerns about climate change are exaggerated. The author is listed as 'Dr. Smith,' but no credentials or affiliations are provided. The website also features numerous advertisements for fossil fuel companies.
10. Based on the scenario, identify at least three red flags that suggest 'ClimateTruth.org' might not be a credible source.
11. What steps should Maria take to verify the information presented in the 'Polar Bears: Thriving, Not Dying!' article?
Use the words below to complete the sentences.
12. A source with strong personal opinions or a hidden agenda likely has a significant .
13. Checking the of a source helps determine if the information is current enough for your research.
14. A credible source demonstrates by presenting information fairly and without undue influence.